Darcy Burton was one of the transformational members of the CMS women's water polo program, joining the Athenas just three years into their status as a varsity program, and earning SCIAC Player of the Year honors twice. She helped CMS to the program's first two SCIAC titles, the first as a sophomore in 1997, when the Athenas upset three-time defending league champion Redlands in the regular season finale by a 9-8 final, and added a second water polo title to cap off her senior season in 1999. Burton had a similar impact on the women's basketball program, leading CMS to the NCAA Tournament as a freshman, and earning All-SCIAC honors twice, while helping CMS to a league title in 1996.