Indira Odamtten was twice named the Scripps Athlete of the Year in her career, which saw her excel on both the soccer and track and field teams. She was a first-team All-SCIAC selection in soccer, earning the team's Best Offensive Player Award, and also earned All-America honors four times in track and field. Her All-America performances included a fifth-place finish in the long jump as a senior in 2000, as well as a seventh-place finish in 1998, while also running on two All-America relay teams. Odamtten helped the women's track and field team to three straight SCIAC titles from 1998-2000, while winning seven individual SCIAC titles. She also scored 142 points in a single league championship, which set a record for an Athena.