After establishing itself as a SCIAC power in the 1980s, Athenas Soccer maintained its prestige in the 1990s, behind the strong play of Maril Davis, who scored a remarkable 106 goals in her career, an average of 26.5 per season, which remains a program record. Davis was a four-time first-team All-SCIAC selection, and led the Athenas to a combined 39-14-3 record in her last three seasons, including 29-6-1 in SCIAC play.  She also earned the SCIAC Player of the Year Award in 1992, and was an All-West Region selection in 1993. Davis was a first-ballot selection to the Ted Ducey CMS Hall of Fame in 2004, ten years after her graduation from Scripps.